Proposal Would Put Recovery of Highly Depleted Pacific Bluefin in Jeopardy

Managers should make progress on long-term strategy, not raise quotas

Navigate to:

Proposal Would Put Recovery of Highly Depleted Pacific Bluefin in Jeopardy
Pacific Bluefin
Proposals to increase catch quotas threaten to derail the recovery of the Pacific bluefin tuna.
Ralph Pace

Pacific bluefin tuna remains a species at risk. Despite a 2017 agreement on a rebuilding plan by countries that catch the species, overfishing that began nearly a century ago continues, leaving this highly valuable fish at less than 4 percent of its historic size—and vulnerable to extinction.

When the managers responsible for Pacific bluefin tuna meet Sept. 2-6 in Portland, Oregon, they must reject proposals from Japan and South Korea that would raise quotas and put the future recovery of the population at risk. Instead, the decision-makers from the Western and Central Pacific Fisheries Commission and Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission, which jointly manage the species, should exercise caution, not increase catch limits, and focus on long-term sustainable management of the fishery.

The rebuilding plan that was passed just two years ago aims to return the species to 20 percent of its historic size by 2034. Japan’s proposal calls for increasing the catch of both juvenile and adult Pacific bluefin, and comes even after countries rejected a similar proposal from Japan last year. Any increase in catch quotas would exacerbate overfishing and delay or derail the chances of a recovery. Additionally, recovery depends on an increase in recruitment—an estimate of the number of new fish entering the population in a given year—but signs point to a possible decrease in recruitment last year. Managers should wait for the results of an official stock assessment, scheduled for next year, to confirm if the plan is working before even considering raising the bluefin quota.

Effective management should be based on responsible, sustainable quotas and stock assessments that account for uncertainty, not on overly optimistic expectations that recruitment will increase and then remain high. The constant back-and-forth on quotas for Pacific bluefin reinforces the need to agree on a science-based, precautionary harvest strategy that is tested in computer simulation. Modernizing bluefin management in this way will result in a more automated, transparent, predictable—and effective—system that moves away from contentious yearly debates to more forward-thinking, strategic planning.

Long-term, sustainable, international management is the last hope that any gains in the Pacific bluefin population won’t be immediately reversed by future decisions prioritizing short-term profit. At this year’s meeting, managers and the countries that depend on a healthy Pacific bluefin population must demonstrate their commitment to science-based, precautionary management by maintaining the established rebuilding plan and making progress by adopting a robust and sustainable harvest strategy for the species.

Jamie Gibbon is a manager with The Pew Charitable Trusts’ international fisheries team.

Bluefin
Bluefin
Article

Tuna Managers Should Reject Proposal to Increase Catch of Pacific Bluefin

Quick View
Article

Pacific bluefin tuna is a species at risk. Despite recent agreement on a rebuilding plan for this valuable fish, the rate of fishing continues at more than twice the sustainable level. Further, four of the five top fishing nations for Pacific bluefin have gone over their catch limits in the past two years, demonstrating little commitment to following the rules and improving the status of the stock.

Pacific Bluefin tuna
Pacific Bluefin tuna
Article

Pacific Bluefin Tuna Stock Remains Highly Depleted, New Science Shows

Quick View
Article

This week, the scientists who evaluate the health of Pacific bluefin tuna, one of the most iconic and valuable fish species in the world, released a new stock assessment that shows the population at just 3.3 percent of its unfished level. This confirms the species’ severely depleted status and points to the continued need for more effective management of the fishery.

Bluefin Tuna
Bluefin Tuna
Article

Brighter Future for Pacific Bluefin Tuna

Quick View
Article

The Pacific bluefin tuna is among the most depleted species on the planet, having been fished down more than 97 percent from its historic, unfished size. For years, this prized fish has been in dire need of strong policies that would reverse that decline, but the two organizations responsible for its management—the Western and Central Pacific Fisheries Commission (WCPFC) and the Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission (IATTC)—failed in their recent efforts, allowing overfishing to continue and further risking the future of the species.