America’s Electric Grid: Growing Cleaner, Cheaper and Stronger

Report October 27, 2015 Read time:

Projects: Clean Energy Initiative

Electricity is illuminating, but its generation, transmission, and distribution have long been opaque. Cleaner, Cheaper, Stronger: Industrial Efficiency in the Changing Utility Landscape reports on how the once static utility industry is becoming a dynamic and transformative opportunity for the nation’s economic, environmental, and energy future.

An array of technological, competitive, and market forces are changing how the U.S. generates power and the ways that Americans interact with the electric grid. A century-old centralized system is yielding to advanced, distributed-energy generation capabilities—in which power is produced at or near the place where it is consumed—that allow the industry to respond to new market opportunities and evolving consumer desires.

The report concludes with an evaluation of the impact of key regulatory and legislative policies on the deployment of industrial energy efficiency technologies in order to help federal policymakers effectively encourage adoption of these systems. The Pew Charitable Trusts commissioned ICF International Inc. to model these policies and found that implementation of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Power Plan and an improved federal investment tax credit could result in a 27 percent increase in adoption by 2030.

Download the report.

Downloads Distributed Generation: Cleaner, Cheaper, Stronger (PDF)

Key Findings

$150 billion The amount electricity blackouts cost U.S. businesses every year

From 2000 to 2014, outages increased six fold from 2.5 to almost 18 disruptions a month. The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) estimates that these events cost U.S. businesses as much as $150 billion per year. Although there is no doubt that aging, antiquated power infrastructure contributes to the increased number of outages, the rise in the number and intensity of weather events is also a major contributing factor.

Tweet
300 Number of US. electric grid disturbances from 2011-2013, more than any other developed nation.

Because the U.S. electric grid is antiquated and vulnerable to outages, the American Society of Civil Engineers in 2013 gave the system a D+ grade in its regular assessment of major U.S. infrastructure. And in a recent survey, senior utility executives rated aging infrastructure as the top issue facing the industry.

Tweet
90% Share of new power capacity that came from gas and renewable energy sources since 2000

For the foreseeable future, natural gas and renewable power plants will account for virtually all new capacity installed in the United States, and the fleet of coal plants will continue to contract. In addition, independent operators and rooftop solar generators will produce more electricity.

Tweet
27% Amount that enhanced tax policies could boost WHP and CHP deployment by 2030

The extension of the same investment tax credit that other clean energy sources receive to combined heat to power and waste heat to power for 2017 and 2018 could increase deployment by 26 percent over today’s installed capacity. Similarly, implementation of EPA’s Clean Power Plan could result in 23.5 percent increased deployment by 2030. Taken together, an enhanced ITC and the Clean Power Plan policies would increase CHP and WHP deployment by 27 percent above today’s current installation levels.

Tweet

OVERVIEW

Electricity is illuminating, but its generation, transmission, and distribution have long been opaque. Today, however, the once static utility industry is becoming a dynamic and transformative opportunity for the nation’s economic, environmental, and energy future.

At the root of this evolution are years of flat electricity demand—the result of efficiency improvements; expanded, cost-effective, clean, and efficient generation options; changing expectations for energy infrastructure, such as an increased priority on reliability and security; and enhanced standards for controlling pollutants. These behavioral and economic shifts are driving the nation toward cheaper, cleaner energy sources and a decentralized fleet of power generators with growing competition. They also are putting pressure on businesses and policymakers to adapt to the evolving marketplace.

Distributed generation is not a passing fad, and new technologies pose significant challenges to long-standing business models. Utilities at the forefront of adoption and innovation are pursuing business and regulatory changes that will allow them to embrace and prosper in a new, less centralized future. At the other end of the spectrum, some utilities are trying to preserve the traditional model. And in the middle, the balance of the utility sector, also referred to in this analysis as the utility industry, is striving to understand and work with changing conditions. As the established industry struggles to modernize, more recent entrants to the sector—from solar energy and efficiency service companies to telecommunications and home security firms—are offering new goods and services in the electric marketplace.

Advancements that enable distributed generation will continue and probably gain momentum, but reluctant utility players could slow progress and delay realization of significant benefits such as a shift toward cleaner technologies. At the same time, the distributed electricity future must include and engage the utility sector; otherwise, the system could face reliability issues, fall short in capital investments, and produce higher power bills.

Historically, the U.S. utility industry has done a tremendous job meeting the key societal challenge of providing reliable electricity to the entire country. Now, as recent polling shows, the public is demanding a cleaner, cheaper, and more decentralized energy future, and involving the utility industry in the growth of distributed generation should accelerate progress toward meeting those goals. For these reasons, the national interest will be best served if utilities take an active role in the energy revolution and ensure a healthy, innovative utility sector using clean, smart, and economically promising distributed energy resources.

This report examines the history of the changing electric grid to understand why and how it is evolving. It then looks at industrial energy efficiency technologies, sometimes referred to as cogeneration, and focuses on how this type of distributed generation—which includes combined heat and power (CHP) and waste heat to power (WHP)—can contribute to a cleaner, more secure, and more resilient electric grid.

These systems, which capture waste heat to produce power and/or heat or cool buildings, can help achieve national economic, environmental, and energy goals.

Downloads Distributed Generation: Cleaner, Cheaper, Stronger (PDF)

The national interest will be best served if utilities take an active role in the energy revolution and ensure a healthy, innovative utility sector using clean, smart, and economically promising distributed energy resources.