Growth in Personal Income Shows Uneven U.S. Recovery

Article April 19, 2016 Read time:

Projects: State Fiscal Health

Note: These data have been updated. To see the most recent data and analysis, visit Fiscal 50

One of the longest U.S. economic expansions in history has lifted personal income in all states. But growth has varied, from a constant annual rate of less than 1 percent in Nevada to more than 5 percent in North Dakota since the start of the Great Recession. A handful of states, though, lost some gains in the fourth quarter of 2015.

Nationwide, growth in personal income has been slower than normal. Since the downturn began in the fourth quarter of 2007, estimated U.S. personal income has increased by a constant annual rate of 1.6 percent through the fourth quarter of 2015, compared with 2.8 percent over the past 30 years, after accounting for inflation.

States have recovered at different paces. Adjusted for inflation, personal income in 21 states has grown faster than in the nation as a whole since the start of the recession. Only in mid-2015 did the final state—Nevada—recover its personal-income losses and return to its pre-recession level.

In the latest year of this post-recession expansion, all but six states continued to make gains. Personal income in the fourth quarter of 2015 fell from a year earlier in Iowa, Nebraska, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Dakota, and Wyoming. Despite the drops, personal income in those states remained higher than before the recession. Overall, inflation-adjusted personal income grew by 2.9 percent at the close of 2015 compared with a year earlier, with 17 states outpacing U.S. growth.

Personal income estimates are widely used to track state economic trends. As the economy expands or shrinks, state personal income also changes. These trends matter not only for individuals and families but also for state governments, because tax revenue and spending demands may rise or fall along with residents’ incomes. Comprising far more than simply employees’ wages, the measure counts all sorts of income received by state residents such as earnings from owning a business or investing, as well as benefits provided by employers or the government.

Download the data

Trends in inflation-adjusted personal income since 2007, the onset of the recession:

North Dakota (5.1 percent) enjoyed the fastest annualized growth since the start of the recession, measuring by the constant pace it took for personal income to reach current levels. Next were other leading oil-producing states: Texas (3.0 percent), Alaska (2.6 percent), Oklahoma (2.3 percent), and Colorado (2.2 percent).
Nevada, where home prices and construction earnings plunged when the housing bubble burst, had the slowest growth among all states: an annualized rate of just 0.2 percent since the fourth quarter of 2007.
After Nevada, Illinois (0.6 percent), Maine (0.8 percent), Connecticut (0.8 percent), and Arizona (0.9 percent) had the slowest annualized growth rates for personal income.

Trends in personal income for the fourth quarter of 2015, adjusted for inflation and compared with a year earlier:

The fastest growth rates in the fourth quarter of 2015 relative to a year earlier were in a cluster of Western states: California (5.1 percent), Oregon (4.1 percent), Utah (4.1 percent), and Nevada (3.9 percent).
Among the six states with a drop in personal income, North Dakota (-3.7 percent) and Wyoming (-1.2 percent) were hurt primarily by declining earnings in the mining industry, which includes coal, natural gas, and oil production. Iowa (-1.4 percent), South Dakota (-0.9 percent), and Nebraska (-0.6 percent) mainly registered losses in the farm sector, and Oklahoma (-0.3 percent) saw declines in farming, mining, and manufacturing income.
Although 44 states registered gains, personal income in two grew by less than 1 percent: West Virginia (0.5 percent) and Kansas (0.8 percent). Farm earnings fell in Kansas, and the mining industry stunted West Virginia’s growth.
At the end of 2015, nine states saw growth in personal income that the Bureau of Economic Analysis attributed to bonuses paid when auto workers ratified new union contracts: Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Missouri, Michigan, Ohio, Tennessee, and Texas.

Personal income in 38 states grew faster between the fourth quarters of 2014 and 2015 than its constant pace since the end of 2007, accelerating those states’ economic expansions. In six states—Alaska, Idaho, Kansas, New Mexico, Texas, and West Virginia—personal income increased in the past year but did so at a slower pace than each state’s constant growth rate since the recession, moderating their growth trends. Among the six states with declines over the past year, North Dakota had the largest drop but still enjoyed the greatest growth within the U.S. for inflation-adjusted personal income since the recession’s onset.

By other measures, states’ recovery from the recession also is uneven. According to Pew’s Fiscal 50 research, 21 states still were collecting less tax revenue, after adjusting for inflation, in the second quarter of 2015 than at their individual peaks before or during the recession. Meanwhile, employment measures show that many states’ labor markets have yet to completely recover.

Some ups and downs since recession

The constant rate of growth between 2007 and 2015 masks volatility in personal income that occurred in intervening calendar years. (See the “Year by year” tab for annual results in each state between 2007 and 2015. Because year-by-year results are based on changes in total dollars of personal income from calendar year to calendar year, those results cannot be compared with growth rates in the 50-state chart that measure changes in annualized fourth-quarter data from a year-earlier period.)

Measuring total dollars of personal income received in each calendar year, this economic gauge fell in every state in 2009. The country rebounded over the next three years: 49 states’ personal income rose in 2010—Nevada was the outlier—and all states saw increases in 2011 and 2012. In 2013, personal income fell in 39 states, reflecting a number of taxpayers shifting income to 2012 from 2013 to avoid potential increases in certain federal tax rates, and the expiration of other tax rates. The rebound resumed over the next two years, with personal income rising in every state but Kansas in 2014. For calendar 2015, personal income was higher than in 2014 in all but three states: Iowa, North Dakota, and South Dakota.

What is personal income?

Personal income tallies residents’ paychecks, Social Security benefits, employers’ contributions to retirement plans and health insurance, income from rent and other property, and benefits from public assistance programs such as Medicare and Medicaid, among other items.

Federal officials use state personal income to determine how to allocate support to states for certain programs, including funds for Medicaid. State governments use personal income statistics to project tax revenue, set spending limits, and estimate the need for public services.

Looking at personal income per capita or state gross domestic product, which measures the value of all goods and services produced within a state’s borders, can yield different insights on state economies.

Download the data to see state-by-state growth rates for personal income from 2007 through the fourth quarter of 2015. Visit The Pew Charitable Trusts’ interactive resource, Fiscal 50: State Trends and Analysis, to sort and analyze data for other indicators of state fiscal health.

Analysis by Alex Boucher, Ruth Mantell, and Jennifer Thornton